My most hated Wigan player of all time was John Holdsworth

Who did you play under at brook?

So many wigan players I've hated over the years but Skerritt (sp) and Cowie stand out from past days, Edwards was just a supreme winner/highly motivated but imo overrated (By Wiganers of course ) as a player.

Mick Cassidy was another average player with a chip on his overpaid shoulder

Ryan Bailey is a joke, you know your bad when your fellow professionals think your pathetic. Scully's exact words were 'always 3rd man in first man out'.

Funny really because the players who stand out for me were those of limited talent. Players like Hanley , Farrell , Robinson etc who were geniune world class players I always had a grudging respect for.

Terry Newton was probably the player of modern times who stood out for me and maybe the exception to the 'average player' tag. He had talent and he was hard as nails but he spoiled it all by being a dirty sod, his assault on his 'mate' Sean Long was just disgusting.

And Scullys one who would know, ask Andy Farrell.

Farrell was a good player , as a prop or second row. TBH he should have been at prop well before the last season when he was shifted there. He fancied himself as a standoff which he clearly wasnt. Scully was a proper ball playing loose forward ...

Get a dvd of the 2004 Cup Final and watch Scullys "tackle" on Kevin Brown. Faz was bigger, faster, stronger, a better kicker.

Look at their respective points scoring records. Game set and match.

I think Andy Faz was very overrated but I put that down to the muppets on sky building him up to be something he wasn't and he's pron my most hated Wigan player for that reason but I suppose Eddie and stevo turned me against him getting hard on over him.

I must admit he was very good in his first full season at Wigan and was possibly world class in that last season as a prop.

I think I'm pretty fair in assessing players no matter who they play for, I might not like certain players but I'm big enough to say they are good players but I don't think Faz was a patch on scully.

Should we put it on the "to be discussed list" for GF. The way we are going we'll be pi$$ed and watch the game in the club on t.v.

Now your grasping at straws, Scully was certainly smaller but I wouldnt be too sure he was weaker, he was certainly stronger in defence and had more skill going forward, Farrell relied on his size and bulk more (I admit nobody could throw a 30 yard forward pass quite like Farrell). As for kicking, Farrell was Wigans undesputed no1 , Scully didnt like the job and did it when he had too. For GB they were both worth a spot, Faz in the second row, prop as he got older Scully as 13 every single time. If I had to choose between them I'd have Scully in my team every day of the week.