Thought his tackling was spot on !! His not everyone's cup of tea and I no it's only one game but that's what everyone's problem with him was his defence

I dont think gaskell tackling is too bad it's just sometimes he can get caught out of position

If u look at posts to do with him they all say he shouldn't play cause lance is better defensively that's there opinions

I've never had a problem with any of Gaskell's play, defensive or otherwise. All he has lacked is a bit of experience to aid his decision making and if that time had been afforded to him last season we (well, me at least) wouldn't be sweating on this contract business.

I would be gutted if we lost him.

Gaskell is a player we need to keep hold of. He has a good organisational and kicking game which is a rare amongst emerging halfbacks, it tends to be a lot more orientated around a running game.

Ditto.

Thought he played really well last night, linked up well with Lomax to put Wello over, and his defence was superb. Wilkin took a lot of pressure off him in relation to his kicking game, allowing Gaskell to focus on other areas.

He does have a great understanding with Lomax, they understand each other extremely well and bring the best out of each other.

I hope he starts the season at 6, and has a cracking season. He is the sort of player who if we sold, could come back to haunt us.

Agreed

Decision making's his only real shortcoming for me. I wouldn't call it greedy, but there're times when he should let the ball go and doesn't. It's easy to see from the stands or on TV, but I think if Gaskell improves his decision making, he can become a very good stand off.

Agreed, which is why I was very frustrated by the end of last year as his decision making would not improve in the under 21's as there is no need to if you can beat the man.

You can only improve by making the mistake and learning from it.

definitely leaving at the end of the season (unless he is lying to his close friends and family).

Wigan bound

Decision making generally improves with experience. Same in any walk of life really. He missed a whole year which means he is now back behind Lomax in his development at first grade level. Therefore, we have to step back a season for Gaskell in our expectations, which is a real shame because had he been our six last season then by now we might have been watching real improvement in his decision making.

But let's not forget that even the great James Roby makes wrong decisions sometimes. In the friendly on Friday there were a couple of really naff passes from Robes, just as there are from all players on occasion.

His decision making was my only complaint with Gaskell when he cemented his place in the team at the back end of 2011. The grand final against Wigan was the perfect example, he was very dangerous with the ball and IMO our best player in attack but time and time again he took the wrong option.

After that Grand final, I thought we should have Kept the Gaskell and lomax combination for 2012 and let them develop, his decision making could only improve by playing with the first team players and gaining experince and a understanding but unfortunately we signed a fullback to take his place and some crazy coaching decisions seen him out the team.

Erm, the Grand Final in 2011 was against Leeds btw. Gaskell was nowhere near the first team in 2010, when we lost to Wigan.

Thank goodness this season we don't start the season as grand final losers again. Clean slate, fresh start.

I,m wondering if most of his problem was the lack of a technical coach the last couple of seasons, Gaskell on his debut was a very promising half back who seemed to get worse on his decision making as these seasons unfolded. We all know Lance isn,t a half back and even he was very poor on his decision making which put a lot of un needed pressure on Lomax. Hopefully Mr Brown will structure our half back play to allow Lomax and Gaskell to operate as "one", instead of the fragmented 6 and 7 we have had to endure for 2 seasons.
Hopefully this season Lance will start most of the games starting on the bench and replacing Roby and Wellens sometimes during the game.
Lee Gaskell needs to take the bull by the horns now, enjoy his rugby and prove to himself how could a player he could be and decide also which club it is going to be with.