It was not clumsy,as you keep saying, I was a vicious pre meditated high tackle and replays did not make it look worse than it was. Meli has broken his arm because of the force used.

It was clumsy. Your description is a joke and shows you dont have a clue of the meaning of the words you actually type. The alternative is your trolling.

I once broke my arm tacking someone legally so that getting injured proves nothing.

There arnt many 'vicious' or 'pre meditated' challenges these days although I have seen a few , most of them were commited by the late Terry Newton and I remember a couple by our very own Sonny Nickle.

Your description as "clumsy" is the joke. This is how most people saw it including the Rfl Disciplinary panel,and explains why Meli escaped a longer ban.

Rule: 15.1(b) Detail: High Tackle – Intentional – stiff arm tackle – no attempt to tackle legitimately – violent Grade E

The committee are no doubt this was a serious act of misconduct and had the potential for serious injury which thankfully did not occur. The committee give the player credit for admitting guilt to a very reckless tackle. The player does have an excellent disciplinary record over a 15 year first grade career in Super League and the NRL and feel that a 4 match suspension and a £300 is appropriate in this in instance.

The above highlighted statements will tell you that it was not deliberate (Word not used at all in RFL report) and Meli is not, in any way, that type of player.

Welham will be out for 4to6 weeks thanks to Brown's tactics and it's a wonder Hall's neck wasn't broken!
Brown was a dirty coach when he was at Huddersfield, shame really Saints have always been a team I have enjoyed watching until now.

Dirty team , dirty coaching eh .. hmmm like maybe getting players to attack standing legs and ending someones season.

Hull KR are historically that type of club. Always had a couple of players to do the dirty work! Ending an players season/career has never bothered them before.