He was garbage. Did most things poorly and went hiding for large periods.

So now you're agreeing with what I've said (and been pilloried for) for about five or six years. I'll reiterate, he is, along with Paul McShane, Tommy Lee and Shaun Ainscough probably the most overrated YOUNG player I have ever seen.

All were very good at 16 or 17 years of age, but never progressed well enough.

I've never been 100% convinced on him making a super league player. He certainly had potential but without the right attitude then he's not worth having.

If we can't rely on him during an emergency like this then he may as well go now.

His entire career is really hanging by a thread

It all depends which comes first, 3 or 4 games to find some form for the team or 3 or 4 games to get injured.

Being a confidence, fragile player to get us through the play offs is very low percentage.

Let's be honest, he's been stealing a living off saints for a good few years now. I couldn't care less if he wins man of the match every game for the rest of the season, I'd still get shut of him.

He's had enough chances.

Mid his contract up at the end of the year?

Is his contract up at the end of the year?

yup, you wouldnt think it, but he's playing for his career

You missed out the winning choice
He plays all of the remainaing games, looks garbage in most, plays well in 2 and is then hailed as the new saviour by some short term memory posters.

Thats my choice

If we get to the grand final and that's the only game he plays great in and that helps us win then I'll personally carry him around on a purple cushion hailing him as the next God for a whole year.

If, Perhaps and Maybee.
That's Garry all right.

On a positive note, the more poor performances he keeps churning out the closer he is to having a good game, so which team do you want it to be against Wakefield, Leeds, Warrington or Huddersfield.