I listened to the game on Wish FM , i couldn't be d watching on the Tele as the weather was too nice to be stuck indoors although i did keep going indoorsto see the tries/good bits...one of the commentators was Paul Clough (current injured saints player) and even he said it shouldn't have been a penalty...i actually thought that he was very unbiased throughout the game

He said his injury was an 'unusual one' something to do with nerves in the neck,so he couldn't identify any definate target date at the moment,but felt that it was going well

Sorry, double post

Thanks mate

Did Washbrook make contact with Ashe whilst he was in the air though?

Yes I think he did

Yes he did and you can, a player cannot tackle the opposing player while in the air. Washbrook was going for the ball and there's no way that a penalty should have been given.

However, on the bias front... Stevo and Eddie?

Whereas I don't think he looked like someone taking a position to catch the ball. He shouldered Ashe mid air.

It was a 50/50 call at best and I think Ganson made the right call.

There was a real set to in the Sky box. I thought there were going to be fisticuffs at one point!

I too thought it probably wasn't a penalty, but lets get back on track here, we're talking about Clarke's bias throughout the whole 80 minutes

We all know about Clarke's love interest with Wigan. As for Eddie and Stevo, they were creaming when you started to get back in the game. Granted it was good drama, but I sensed they wanted the 'comeback kings' to do it again.

As for the final penalty, it's beyond me. Cost us the win IMO, was never a penalty in a million. Saying that, we should have never lost the lead in the first place.

Good show for the neutral and the game of RL, though.

I think most people on here would also think you should never have got that lead vis-a-vis the shocking forward pass that lead to one of KY's tries.
If the correct decision had been made there then the penalty debate is irrelevant

If you can't beat us at home with our team weakened beyond recognition, it says as much about Hull's lack of title contender credentials as it does about Saint's resilience.

If that the case why do your lot boo a player that sign for another club ..Will you be booing the other player who has signed for the Aussie club

I'm surprised no one has mentioned the worst decision of the afternoon and one which Saints scored from.

When Meli kicked the ball Whiting had his feet on the touchline when he caught the ball, and was therefore out of play. The head and feed should have gone to Hull but went to Saints. Roby scored direct from that scrum and got Saints back unto the game.

I thought I saw it that way "live" on t.v.

I've just watched boots n all the tries and that's exactly what happened. Whiting did not carry the ball over the touchline.