I wouldn't put Morley alongside him either, though he did have a good season this year. Peacock and Graham stand head and shoulders above the rest.

i think peacock's star is fading, just my opinion

It is, but that's what happens when you hit 30.

i'm sorry but i'll have to raise you Paul "Baloo" Anderson on that one

Rubbish

He was always better its just that you lot didnt see it until he joined worldclasssupasaints then all of a sudden he was ace. Convenient that.

so what are you arguing?

that his level of performance above the age of 30 was grossley over exaggerated by Saints fans that are famous for this. Contary to what you wrote, he was clearly in decline above the age of 30 but the fact that you had never appreciated how good he was before joining you prevented you from seeing this.

My, my. Some people are bitter.

Baloo admitted himself the Saints staff got him fitt! He was a unfit fat git at Bradford, rather than a fitt fat git at Saints.

Its true. How many players are suddenly transformed into world class when they went to Saints then back again when they left?

Higham? V Anderson? Ive even seen Lyon called not as good as Gidley the minute he was gone. Leon Pryce branded one of the best 6's in the world and all you youngsters are the next Lyon like Tyrer and Foster until they are shipped out. Scott Moore was branded the next superstar scrum half until you hipped him out then after having a half decent season at best he i brought back off loan and low and behold he is awesome again.

He was an international prop at Bradford and a damn good one. You didnt credit him with this until he came to the worldclasssupasaints and magically became world class.

I don't think Nobby believed how good he was.

He was overweight and one dimensional especially towards the end at bradford, lucky to get 2 ten minute spells out of him.

I was always concerned when he entered the fray against us but after a few big runs he became easily subdued.

Eyebrows were raised when he joined us but he didn't come for a last pay packet he came to play and we would kill for him to add to our pack now.

If he had joined Saints earlier his star would have risen higher.

and there you have it. The proof of how obnoxious and arrogant Saints fans are.

Overall Graham is better then the lot of them imo. He's easily better then the last 2 and even though he probably doesn't quite have that aura about him the first 2 have he offers more solely as a player.

He's the best prop in Britain without question.

That's totally pathetic.

Nobby has probably done the same thing with Feka. It wouldn't surprise me if the new guy turned Feka into a sphelt tackling machine and thus a much more effective player rather than the overweight ten minute pudding he was last season. But if this happens will you say Wigan fans are arrogant for saying that one coach brought the best out of a player when the previous coach did not?