to be fair he has no depth perception

Meli's problem is that his brain farts invariably cost us tries, same as Gardners did. That tends to outweigh his good points in some matches.



I agree that not all tries conceded are down to the last person to miss a tackle, however you aren't going to stop an opposition player putting a kick in and him not taking kicks is down to him, no one else.



Maybe it's because we've had a very unsettled half back combination this year? We've been lucky in the last few years that neither Long nor Pryce have been out for any length of time, that settled combination has not been there this year with a number of players playing in the halves. We've also had Cunningham and Roby out for longer periods than usual. All of this has contributed to our lack of fluency in attack.

Harsh perhaps, but they were the chinks that opened up our defence.

Those two penalties (the first one being very dumb, the second more understandable) were on the last tackle. He gave Leeds another set of six in out 10-20 metre zone, good sides make that kind of error pay and Leeds are a damn good side.

Disagree. Our defence failed to cover properly.

He made his mistakes, yes, but he also played some good plays, like the kick back down field after their kick out of play. That reminded me of the old Longy and it was good to see. I hope we see much more of that for the remainder.

Last night Meli dropped one pass and one bomb (okay a shocking drop - but still only one) the other dropped bomb had already been blown for a penalty by Long. Even his dropped bomb didnt cost us a try - just field position.
Its amazing that 2 mistakes, neither of which resulted in a direct try now makes his overall performance "the worst ever" - you just illustrate my point that people focus on obvious mistakes and build their own case around that.



Its a lot easier (and not usually the wingers responsibility) if the opposition have to kick from their own half or just in yours rather than the 30 m line when they will put pressure on wingers.



So in other words if we lose a player then we are unable to cover his position with another player who is capable of running training moves in a real life situation - if that is the case then we will have problems next year

wello got no where catching that kick so I take he's not enough then? Or is it ok because he St helens lad?

The wasn't only meli that made mistakes. Longy made them all night, wello dropped a kick, tony p give a pen away that put the game out of reach.

Yet meli had better game than all them but gets bagged again

do our wingers not practice catching kicks, serious question, a hour everyday would improve it surely, so do we do it? and if not, why not?

Meli has been one of our better players all season. Anyone who disagrees or slags him off is lacking in understanding of the modern rugby league game. He offers more than Gardner, who is a very poor winger, and does a lot of hard work covering for our lack of weight in the forwards.

Give the guy a chance!!!!!

I agree with everything you say mate, I'm not his biggest fan either.

He ran better than any of our backrows.