I've read two.
I thought Joynt's was good. I really enjoyed reading about the changes in the game around '96 froma player's persepective.
Scully's was OK.

i know many of you wont read it but terry newtons was a good read.

Not sure where the OP is coming from Joynt's book was very good.

I would recommend Barrie McDermotts, Stevo's , Mike Gregory's and Radlinskis. Longy's had some of the best tales away from the game itself as you would expect. Sculthorpe's was a bit of a dry read.

Long's was very very poorly written.

I imagine the Alker book to have a few pages that are worth reading but then be a big miss in others.

Long's was a piece of fiction, in parts whereas Joynt and Scully wrote about the times and the changes to the game. Newlove's put to bed the story that he wouldnt fly, although very short in content it was a reasonable read

Quite liked the Alex Murphy one.

Which Alex Murphy one ? I think there are about three of his in print at the moment. Not that I'm saying Alex is trying to make the tales of his career spread out or anything.

The Saint/Sinner one.

This is one of the best RL books I have read really enjoyed it.

Another good read is Andrew Johns' autobiography...would possibly say that is the best I have read imo, some funny stories, good origin tales and a bit of controversy mixed in

Exactly what I look for in an auto.

Longy's was entertaining even if the spelling mistakes were terrible. John Monie's was ok to read if a little unexciting , his comments on Wane are amusing

I have waiting to be read

Barrie Mac's
Scully's
Lockers

stanley genes book is pretty good

Simply rad was ok, well written but pretty bland a bit like joynts , Longy's was like him very entertaining, I wouldnt expect a pie eater to appreciate it though.

12 'Long' years of having their nose rubbed in it by Sean evidentley still hurts...