I'd like him to stay.

Reading between the lines, and i may be wrong, it sounds like we have maybe been looking at other possibilities for the wing position, and things aren't decided for that position.

Or that he's been looking waiting for offers from clubs back home to appease his wife?

I hope he stays. He has played well this season and we will still need some experience in the centres and wings next season. It's no use having a great pack if there is no one to finish of the moves.

i hope he goes, his defense is terrible, if a high ball goes to his wing, they always score of it, yes hes good in attack but he is the wordt in the league at defending

Deserves another year been outstanding this year even though restricted by injury. By far and away his best season for us.

Cant tackle, cant catch and slower than the proverbial tax rebate. how anyone would want to keep him is beyond me.

He has played really well but I would like to see replacements
for both wingers.

It is ok to want another year but his record in visa applications,
domestic commitment to St Helens , and some big match howlers
do count against him for me.

Meli is the best winger at saints by a long way, he's also one of the very few players we have that can break a tackle and make a break.

His mistakes seem to cost us big time, we would have won last two grand finals if it wasn't for his cock ups.

Saints should see what players are about before we offer him a year deal.

I would 100% try to get shut of gardner, he is utter $hit.

On Sunday we adopted a system where lomax and wellens dropped back and meli stayed in the line, this resulted in us being virtually perfect against high balls, with another big, tough defender in the line. I feel this is something we could continue with

I say keep him for another year.
(quite the opposite of what I was saying 3 months ago).

Sign him up, the blokes a dude. Feed him and he will score. Sign him up now or 1 more go. And lets get the word out to the world that we need 2 new wingers, applications to be sent to st helens rlfc CO widnes rlfc

He still stood by, though, while two tries were scored.

And scored some no other winger in the league could, that's who he is it's frustrating, but it's never boring!

That sums up what it's like watching Saints.