Quote Charlie Sheen="Charlie Sheen"I thought Swift played well for you, although apart from Savelio non of the forwards turned up, really. It may just be me, but I'm not sure what Greenwood does to warrant the hype. He's a big unit, and he runs good lines near the try line, but is his all round contribution good enough?'"
He's a big unit and he runs big lines, and for his age that is a good enough contribution IMO. On an 'ins' line near the try line he's very difficult to stop. His footwork into tackling is a bit poor at the minute as are his reads in defence, but that will come with experience. Worthy of the hype for a young player having his first real break out year, just not England quality (yet) like some people have made out. He also needs to carry the ball more coming out of our own half I think.
Quote Charlie Sheen="Offside Monkey"However, we are (again) being totally out played at the ruck. We never show the ability to slow the oppositions PTB, whilst allowing them to slow ours. This is the greatest problem we have by far.'"
There are two main elements to this.
1: we plant our feet when tackling way too early. We get away with it against teams like Wigan, where it's all straight/diagonal lines from their ball runners, because it just means we have more time to get set before a collision. Against teams with footwork i.e. Warrington, Leeds, they find weak tackles as a result. Thompson is the worst for this, but a lot of the team have this problem.
2: we don't have a wrestling coach. I remember this was in part of our defence when a player has a disciplinary hearing earlier in the year. But for me, that's a bit tactically naive. Wrestling is such an important part of the game nowadays, I'm amazed we've lasted this long without one. We as fans don't like slowing the play the ball down, but it is part of the game; Saints refusing to hire a wrestling coach doesn't stop other teams wrestling. We have a few good wrestlers in the team, Flanagan is one (potentially because he's got NRL experience) but they are few and far between.