It is a shame it's a match-up we'll never see. It could have been epic.

Without seeing it, it'd be hard to say either of them is truly the "Best Centre SL has ever seen".

Kirk Yeaman best centre in the league and Puletua better than Graham.

Spot on mate. I remember us being crap but we were never this dull. I enjoy willing like the rest of us but if we cant win I'd at least rather see us go down in style!

I can never remember you guys being crap. When we were winning everything you guys were always there or there abouts. In nearly every final or semi, I know its not winning trophies but you guys were never crap.

Yes.



I assume you're a bigger fan due to thinking he's a better player? I don't dispute that you're a bigger fan of TP, I dispute your sanity and/or eyesight.



If only you could.

And we weren't that crap, a few semis, a few finals - and George Mann

Then you're an idiot.



Then you're a bigger idiot. Puletua is a strong, clean player who lets his rugby do the talking. No ego, no bad sportsmanship. A fine example of a player. Whilst Graham has talent, he is dirty, acts like a spoiled brat when things don't go his way, and is a very bad sport. With some work, I could become a fan of him, but at the moment, I don't want him anywhere near my team.

No doubt you'll try and dress this up as "passion", but I would say Puletua has passion too. As do many great CLEAN players.



That's about as close you can get to "I know you are, you said you are, but what am I" as you can get. Hope you got parental permission before you joined this forum.

thats right

Sorry but I don't agree with that. We have a lot of deadwood in that team at the moment. I'd say we have 1 top class player, a lot of average players and few that are rubbish.

Combine that with a coach that has no idea and we've got problems.

I just hope we have a lot of players off contract next year!

have to disagree,

how many players hae left and joined since last year and the year before? People were not moaning 2 years ago under Anderson.

2yrs is a long time ago pal.Fozz, wello, gidley, pryce and kc are all 2yrs older and not getting better with age.

Also longy, scully, talau, gilmour and few others have moved on so how you can compare this team with the team 2yrs ago?

Scully barely played 2 years ago Soliolo <--(whatever) is as good as Talau on paper and Longy has been replaced by Eastmond

Are you saying the players have gone from good to average or even rubbish or have they always been that?

Same thing happened to us. Eventually you will have a mass exodus from your core and have to rebuild, problem with us is that its still going on 15 years later.

In my opinion Saints have been in decline for the past four years, because in that time they have been in 4 grand finals and 3 CC finals...My standards are alot higher than this and therefore Saints are a spent force.....