Lack of effort? Nonsense. He didn't have a bad game at all. Not spectacular, but made plenty of yards.

You can't ignore the fact that he's not playing in his natural position. He's devastating when he has a bit of room to work with out wide, but it's a different ball game up the middle. The equivalent player at Leeds is Lauitiiti, and I dare say he wouldn't do anywhere near as much damage if he was moved to prop either.

I blame Meli!

3rd highest metre making forward in the SL behind Graham and Peacock.

This is despite missing some games through injury

Excactly, Tony is miles ahead of Lauititi, and leeds love him!

Stop dealing in facts!

Hang on mate thats way out of line.

If you look back at the thread re Tony P much earlier in the season you'll see I said he was overrated then.

Not Fickle at all - never been greatly impressed! so there

Pretty much it, but for the fact that if we lost Tony P, we'd really struggle.

He is one of the few players in the pack capable of carrying defenders with him and off loading.

Has been a good buy and is an important member of the pack.

You really don't like other peoples opinions do you?

He's the 3rd highest meter making forward in the comp as well as one of the highest scoring forwards in the comp.

lol overated.

Brilliant

McClennan's post is spot on, can't add anything to that.



You're entitled to your opinion but were wrong then and by questioning his effort you are certainly wrong now. What are you expecting from him out of interest?

I'm one of tony P's biggest fans, i think he's been phenominal, but exile is entitled to his opinion, but i'd be interested on what he bases it on?

Started strongly, but faded very quickly as the season progressed. Lets hope that he puts the effort in during the play offs......not hopeful though, he seems to be a bit of a waster...