i always say that he never runs the ball with any pace and then just falls to the ground.

Meli didnt have much to do fielding kicks really which is a good job because the ones he did get he mainly c0cked up. Right near the end with us winning he made another mess of one but lucky for us we got away with it.

As per the other comments Meli is ok with his tackling when players are running at him but then you'd expect that from a man as big and strong as him

+
When he dropped that ball, I dropped one too!

Any positive comments about our performance?................... Thought not.
We won FFS and in atrocious conditions. Or were you so geared up mentally for a defeat that you had to come on here anyway and spout negative crap? I really don't know why you bother.

Any positive comments about our performance?................... Thought not.
We won FFS and in atrocious conditions. Or were you so geared up mentally for a defeat that you had to come on here anyway and spout negative crap? I really don't know why you bother.

I think meli has done ok this year but can't take any type of kick. High or along the ground he has huge problems.

Gardner is pretty good under high kick but that's all he's good at.

Gardner is like a magnet to the other teams defence! He just runs straight at the defence. He won't try and beat a man.

He is also very slow and weak in defence.

I'd take meli over him anyday.

Gardner gets boomed nearly every time he takes the ball at the defence.

Can't win Gardner, he got slagged off for running sideways earlier on in his career and now he runs it in hard and straight he's still getting slagged off.

Meli is and if he played for Wigan or Wire we'd all be laughing at him. Does he have to cost us another grand final before people realise what a liability he is.. The arrow from Barrow looks low on confidence, Thankfully Super League is low on good wingers so they get away with it most weeks

Meli did not cost us the Final on his own.

true, but he didn't exactly help either!

Let's face facts. We have Wingers who are good enough to keep us at the top and they have been our 1st choice for 4 years now and in Ade's case a lot longer, however neither of them are anywhere near as good as Uncle Albert was. When Meli or Gardner goes we need an athletic speed merchant similar to Donald. Also I don't care where they come from, whether it be Australia, NZ or Outer Mongolia as long as they can catch, defend and give us back a long range threat which we haven't had since Albert and then Lyon left in all honesty.

If a half decent player with the slightest bit of pace gets through us we are found wanting and we can never ever get back to catch them. Look at Carvell's try vs Wire.

Meli's shirt has always been in jeopardy, but Gardner's form has also been pretty alarming this season. He's still a top-class finisher and his tackling and marking are fine. But the jitters of old have returned to haunt his kick receiving. And that's a major problem if we do get through to the GF to play Leeds because they will target both ruthlessly.

I really think Riley is worth a punt if we could get him. Certainly more speed than we have and something about the lad, always gives it all. Only problem is that he can make a clanger just like anyone and some have been quite bad, but no worse than Meli. Riley is still young. Meli has no improvement in him.