What an embarrassing thread. While probably accidental what Amor did was pretty dangerous. if you're unlucky putting 16 stone of pressure on a guy's head could be tragic. And what with every call going your way at the expense of at least two Cas tries, calling Silverwood for a yellow card for dangerous play is a bit rich. Stay classy lads!

Which two? The second forward pass should have been a try but the first was a mile forward, just look at the line. Its 2m behind when passed and 2m in front when caught.

Come on, don't believe everything the sky idiots say

Well done, great press reporting. Reporting nothing actually posted on this thread.

It's embarrasing when people come on stating that something has been said that has not. Go fishing elsewhere.

People have called it soft, sin-binning sufficient ,mose is fat, and a few other comments. But nothing more than what you have said, it was accidental.

It was only after the linesman saw the replay on the big screen that he ran on and had words with Silverwood.

Deserved sinbin, can't complain if he gets one match ban really. I'd be going bananas if a Wigan player did it!

You cannot be serious.

I am entirely serious. I've never seen a league winger so fat, slow and out of shape. No way was he onside.

It was an akward one to judge, seems as though Amor was caught in 2 minds. The tackle was not complete and it looked as though he wanted to make sure with a smother tackle.
I think he just got the technique wrong, he,s not that type of player to cause intentional injury.

It was careless, nothing more. Sin binning correct and a warning about the "technique" should suffice.

I agree, especially as hes not known for his foul play

Plenty of you saying it was a ridiculous decision. If a Wigan player had done it to a Saints player you'd be on the phone to the police

Having watched the game back the yellow was deserved.

As for Saints getting all the decisions, the massive NFL block that took place the tackle before carney's first try was comical. It's as if ref's are now scared to give obstruction.

Interestingly enough sky didn't really make a lot of it compared with Phil Clarke's 'oh no!!!' with the forward pass call which was an understandable decision given that the player was stood in front of the guy passing the ball

Amor charged grade c
Burns charged grade b