Eamonn, I think is a vital inclusion. Without his help, we would not have such a prosperous future to look forward to.

I also think that the flag is too heavily weighted in favour of players since the 1980's with little to show for Pre ww2.

Granted Saints had little success prior to ww2 however we still had a few great players eg Jack Arkwright, Alf Ellaby, les Fairclough,William Briers

The legendary 1960's sides also seem under represented. Remember these were the best players in the world, not merely good club players as the current generation are.

This is a list of top 10 appearances at Saints
Kel Coslett
William Briers
Billy Benyon
Eric Chisnall
Dougie Greenall
les Jones
George Lewis
John Mantle
Keiron Cunningham
Tom Van Vollenhoven

All these should be on the list

If Cooper is to be replaced I would vote for Rhodes to replace him. I would also suggest that Haggerty is removed and repalced with George Nicholls. I loved watching Roy play but I think we tend to look back with rose-tinted specs a bit and we shouldn't forget his brainfarts. Whole hearted, yes, but not a 'Great' for my money.

agree, we may as well stick Vila Matautia on there if we are putting Roy on.

i know i have already said this but i think we shoud deffinetly have knowsley road on it seen as though we are getting a new ground and most of all all the good memories there.

Find me a picture of KR you could make look remotely artist and wouldnt't clutter it up and we could use it as a background.

how do you insert a picture on this

Put Briers on it.

you need to upload it to somewhere like photobucket then post the image location inside the img tags.

That isn't a fair comparison.

could you not do it. just search on google images

I said, if you can find one we can make artistic, we'll look at it. If it is already hosted online, just copy the image location, and then paste the image location here.

Les Jones might have made a lot of appearances but he wasn't a legend for me.

I posted this on redvee last night following some things posted there and i think it works as a response to some of the posts/opinions here including Chair's about a slight bias toward certain generations.



I think it is much easier for us to look back at players like Newlove who played as part of a succesful team and perhaps put a gloss on our memories of them as a result of the team's achievements during their tenure, much in the same way that the youngest generation of Saints fans are doing with Jamie Lyon right now. These players were undoubtedly terrific, stand-out players in their sides who gave a great service to the red vee during but to include them in such lists in my opinion does a disservice to players like Alan Hunte, Anthony Sullivan, and Paul Loughlin who whilst not costing world record fees or being media darlings contributed no less (and often more in terms of points, tries and appearances and more) to the Saints' cause.