I agree with you to some extent, no point passing to a guy who will just get banjoed. Interesting against Hull Percy gave Grace ball on the wing and he was knocked into touch two or three times.

Grace doesnt yet possess the try scorers instinct of being able to anticipate a break in play and then be in the right position to exploit the break.
Offiah was a superb example of a player who had natural instinct for knowing were to be in order to be on the end of a break, sometimes even before the break had actually occurred. Regan at present tends to ball watch rather than follow play. With his pace and agility together with the breaks the team are now making he should be scoring more, or at the very least be getting involved more. He is reminding me more of Brimah Kebbie at present.

I think the full proof will be when Barba comes into the equation, the magic man has a reputation for being able to cause chaos with even the toughest of defences. If he brings that form into those final 4 games, then Regan should start to score regularly due to the space Barba is creating.

With games being more critical I think you've got too look at Swifty again and see how he responds if picked in the 17. Grace is looking like a player who is getting scared and losing confidence, he,s OK giving him ball with lots of space but defences will be tighter from now on.
Percival is our worse player for errors and is struggling having to cut back inside looking for a support player, Swifty does have better 1-2 combinations and returns the ball back much harder.

Swift has been a first team player for years. He's gash. Try and imagine a player who's even more of a liability than meli and that's swift. He's championship standard at best. Grace is raw yes but until he's done 4 years in the first time like swift it's totally unfair to compare.

Regards

King james

Usually a winger is only as good as his provider (centre), Swifty has every man and his dog inside of him in Josh Jones, Jordan Turner, Dom Peyroux, Tommy Makinson, Ryan Morgan, LMS, Mark Percival, Ashworth etc.
Regan Grace most of his games has had one of the best centres in Superleague in Percival.
Switch that scenario around and I think Grace would be insignificant.

I think they gave Big Al the Man of the match purely cause he was the only player on the pitch not to drop the ball

Really ? Nothing to do with the fact he was the best prop on the pitch by a country mile ?

Swift has played for years and got worse and worse every season. He's not good enough. At least whether Grace will be is still up for debate. It's times like this where man management comes into it. Rest him for a few games, get his confidence back and let him go again. I wouldn't bring Swift in to replace Grace though, that's how bad he is.

I think Grace needs to be taken out of the firing line for a short period to work on his core skills otherwise we will end up with a "Kevin Penny", bringing Swifty back in to see how he responds to wanting that shirt back, could be a win win situation if handled in the right way.