Unless this means we have given up on the hunt for a Winger???

It's not really replacing 2 old wingers if both Ade and Meli go. Makinson is well versed in RL now, he's not really what I would call a youngster. Although it's worrying if we only have 2 wingers for next year in Ade and Makinson.

Surely we should be scouting the Athletics clubs of the UK for their top runners, they will only be drawing down a few £k in lottery funding. For most they will never hit big money in Athletics. It's not beyond the concept of man to find 2 or 3 15 year olds who are lightening fast and train them for 3 years with rugby ball into how to play wing.

According to Brown in his latest statement though contracts aren't simply his choice. They're the result of discussion with Rush and 'all the coaching staff'.

Meli is better than Gardner. So does he get a new deal too? And if not, why not?

To be fair, I've often looked at wingers as poor relations on the pitch. In the junior teams, if a players got the star quality to be a future SL player, you tend to want them getting hold of the ball more often, rather than on the wing, waiting to be serviced.

I'm tempted to agree.
Whilst he has a reasonable track record, there's always this nagging feeling that our faith in brown is slightly misplaced, fueled for me by continuous inclusion of Wellens in key positions and a couple of other bizarre choices on the pitch. I hope its wrong.

Mmm, its obviously a team of guys that cover the signings - scouts to go out and look at players, Mike Rush to overseas the total spend etc, but surely the head coach should be saying "don't resign him (gardner), I need better"?

That's a worrying comment.

You would think so but that doesn't appear to be how it works. Unless there is an element of back covering of course.

Broughton and Briscoe are both out of contract, we should be going for them. They are both young players who can still improve and in Briscoe's case is a current international who can cover a few positions. Gardner and Meli are both out of contract, with their wage we can improve that positon and improve the squad elsewhere with Makinson and Swift fighting it out for the other spot.

Gardner has been a good, solid pro for us but he's bee in and out for the last 2 and a half years due to injury and form, there is no reason to keep him.

Briscoe yes, Broughton no. I really don't see what fans see in him. Yes he's quick, but so was Kevin Penny. There's a reason why he has been at Leeds then Hull then Salford.

I wonder if Briscoe is one of Marwan Koukash's 6 new signings and they are going to "dump" Broughton (on us)?
Perhaps Gaskell is also one of these exciting new signings for them.

On the subject of Ade; I'd possibly give him one year certainly not two.

How much fun would it have been if the good Doctor had decided to save us from anonymity rather than Salford?

Break the bank and sign Dan Norton.

Search for Dan Norton tribute on the site that we daren't mention.

Isn't Saints the logical next step in that sequence?

If I said that there would be uproar.