From a Wigan point of view, Tomkins is leagues above Leuluai, and Leuluai is probably around the same league as Roby/Monaghan, so that answers that one.

I'd love Chase to sign for Wigan. Class act as he showed in the Exiles game.

Some of us take a broader point of view.


S57

Good for you.

W'n

Another point to add to the Chase argument is that when ever other teams play Cas the opposition coach often says we'll have to stop Chase to win, he's often the sole target of the opposition defence who will work on plans to stop him, as stopping him does stop Cas.

I know it is true that other top players in super league are targetted but stopping Tomkins doesn't stop Wigan, stopping Monaghan doesn't stop Warrington and stopping Roby doesn't stop Saints all the top teams have other players to distract the oppositions attention from their superstars, Chase takes all of the attention for himself and quite often is still unstoppable.

As a Cas fan I have obvious bias but I'd not rather have any other player in Super League in my team.

Hope you keep hold of him pal, don't get pillaged, again.

did a silly thing, served his time, end of.

Edited for accuracy

Good to see married life hasn't taken the edge off you, squire.

Give it time.

Dont turn this into another ratboy thread.

I think it works both ways, sometimes it's difficult to shine in a team of poor players but I dont think Cas are that bad. Chase is a top talent but in a top side he may be asked to play in a more structured way

Nobody here cares.

Looelooaye as good as Roby?