The bias Smith shows against Saints is clear. It has been proven time and time again. He will give ANY 50:50 to the other side and will happily contradict a decision he made the previous week to deny Saints a try or award one for the opposition. I've had a few rants about him on here.

So long as the ref is not nobbled by Madge and gorilla man I could not care less.

Same here, i don't care less

What's happened to the quickest ref in superleague, Halibut is he injured or something.

he doesnt deserve to be allowed anywhere near wigan st pats v thatto heath, never mind the play off semi

i know the other refs can be inconsistent at best from one week to the next, but halibut really does take the biscuit

At least he is consistent for both sides.

that's unfair ! he has to be the most improved ref in SL this season ?

I would agree with you there.

I now have a vision of a fish eating a digestive.

Not happy at all with bent 'un after his last display when we played you at the pie dome.

I wonder if he'll award five mysterious penalties in a desperate attempt to keep Wigan in the game?

Probably, plus allowing wigan players to take the odd potshot or two at their opponents heads.

and allow a few kips ontop of our players.