Not rose tinted, just going on what i've seen Smith took us to the grand final in 07 and was dropped for the final, and look what happened. I'm not ready to right him off yet. as for myler i havn't seen enough of him to warrant the hype.

if he has signed an extention this could be a good insurance policy for us.

exactly, kyle's doing better in the centres than he did at 7

Shame to see him go on loan again.

Salford have done well though to replace Myler with a better player.

Smith is a better option than Eastmond and 7 for us.

I'm keeping my options open, but at the same age, smith did a better job at 7 for us

I would suggest that the surrounding team was looking a little better when smith was lining up at 7 for us.

It was definitely, but Smith has show he can do well with a decent team round him, kyle hasn't had the opportunity yet. A big year for both players next year.

You don't seriously believe that, do you mate?

That could have been an anonymous post and I'd still have known it was you. Change the record, move on. Maybe he'll get his chance in 2011 if Kyle doesn't work out at 7.

Because next season in Pryce and Eastmond we have two creative runners but if Im honest cannot see any of these two controlling a game when the team is on the back foot. Smith has a much better positional kicking game than both. It would be a mistake to dismiss smith now while eastmond is untested. Wigan and Long come to mind.....

smith is a good signing for us,he will do well at the willows and look forward to watching him.iv not seen him play so cant tell you if hes better than myler but il tell you now that hes gonna struggle at warrington.the prick messed around with the club and offiah is just as worse

Smith will be at a team that actually have some expectations next year so it will be far more worthwhile having him at Salford than Celtic.

What is Tyrer's situation ATM? Coming back?