Good idea. Gilly is playing as well as Talau did, possibly better in some games. Because of him slipping outside, we are seeing some young guns come through, and getting the best out of established youngsters in the back row.

Overall, it was a very shrewed move.

defo. we havent missed him at all IMO.

I'm sure he would have done the same job he has been doing for years, but his leaving has opened up opportunities for a number of youngsters.

He has clearly lost the plot.

As opposed to stray dogs, concrete, North Road, Pilks and chavs?

Theres a Pilks in Leyland?

IMO his age and the overall age of the squad meant he had to go - We all know we will be replacing quite a few players over the next few years and we cant afford financially or team wise tro do this all at once. Allowing him to leave has meant a space opening up either in the backs or in the back row that is allowing us to develop our young players by giving them all important gametime.

Good move imo

Talau was sacrificed to bring in TP.

I for one thanked Willie for the time and effort he gave us but if i had the choice between TP and Talau, there is no question which i would choose.

Wasnt TP Scully's replacement?

We signed TP in 2007?

Meaning what! That the powers that be where not far sighted enough to see that Scully's playing days were numbered ...... or that Willie was on his way out 12 months earlier but for some grand scheme going wrong

you forgot the [istinky brook[/i

Are you literate though?