No you’re wrong, as I’ve purposely made no judgment of my own on the incident so I had none to reverse. My comment was on the observation and judgment of someone else. I will say now I did see what happened on the tele at the time and my thoughts are (as if you care) Graham seemed to at worst nibbled, more nuzzle the ear, I couldn’t see lots of blood, or even any. I think Graham was silly and the punishment harsh, but that doesn’t change my original comment.