I think most would agree. But most (including those that matter it would seem) would also say that the negatives outweigh the positives

Our penalty count is already far too high, with him in the team we'd be breaking records for penalties conceded.

If he was a prop sure, but we don't need another back rower. As it is he will still get snapped up by some one who thinks they can manage him. For Widnes it's a good deal as they can open up a space for another player and not have to keep hold for 3 years.

I think he's already had enough chances here. Whilst you can't doubt his aggression in defence would be valuable, he just can't seen to iron out the flaws in his character. The positives outweigh the negatives and its such a sad waste of talent.

the day we're happy to take Widnes rejects that have already had a chance at the club is the day i'll turn in my season ticket.

They'll have a kicking game anyway.

Brown got the best out of him at hudds, maybe he could go the same with him at saints. He has taken a few bad boys and got the best out of him over there.

Problem with Scott Moore is he doesn't want to learn his lesson he loves his lifestyle more than he loves his job!

unfortunately the two go hand in hand, without the career he can't have the lifestyle he's used to, but with that lifestyle he can't have that job seemingly.

Very true. I'm actually quite suprised he lasted this long at Widnes.

You mean like a control order or house arrest?

what an absolute tool this boy is