For McNamara to pick Charnley and Hall over Tommy is controversial. To pick Burgess over him as well is laughable. Tommy will enjoy a nice relaxing off season and will benefit for it next season.

Brilliant yesterday, as he has been all season. Take a bow.

How Makinson hasn't been picked is anyone's guess, far better than Charnley and Burgess.

He must have pushed robes for Harry Sunderland. A couple of try saving tackles and a try.

My thoughts exactly, I had him as my MOM followed closely by Thompson, Soliola and Roby.

At the game I thought Roby walked it with Thompson our 2nd best but when watched back I thought robes was still man of the match (I'm biased to robes) with Tommy running him close.

Sia, Manu, Thompson, Richards and Turner also put in good games.

Well should be in the England team, but from a Saints perspective, i'm very glad he's not.

What a game from him. My MOM definitely. But he wasn't alone.

That perfectly timed, crucial tackle in the corner on Liam Farrell just after we went 8-6 up really did save us 4-6 points. Maybe even a match winning tackle in the end.

That performance gives the new coach plenty to think about. IMO on that evidence he's a better fullback than Lomax is.

I disagree, he offered not very much at all in terms on chiming into the line. Then again, there was no halfbacks so it's unfair to judge. You'd have to play them both behind Walsh and Burns to truly find out who's the better full back. I think Lomax would come out on top though.

Not at all convinced about J-Lo. A classy player, but his conditioning worries me. It'll be interesting to see how he goes next year, particularly in terms of how many games he plays.

I think Swift could be a better FB than both Makinson and Lomax.

Absolutely outstanding display from Tommy on Saturday night, bordering on faultless actually. Both he and Sia definitely ran Robes close for MOTM.

I think so too, can beat a man easily and he has amazing pace from a standing start

Swift can become a better running full back than both.

Tommy can become a better defensive full back than both.

Jonny can become a better organising and play making full back than both.


All have pros and cons but I think the more rounded and better across all areas is Lomax.