Exactly as the title says, a complete joke. We let tries in that a u11's side would be ashamed of.

That second half was a joke

P.S can somebody please explain to me what Flanders offers this season ahead of the excellent Dixon

makes for great rugby so enjoy it while it last

can't you bring yourself to give credit to the Catalans FFS ?

Totally Agree with the topic starter. Great Catalan play for the final try but the soft tries we let in at the start of the second half were defensively diabolical. They were waltzing in on the 2nd and 3rd tackles.

Pryce's arm did hit the ground in the lead up to the gld but we got some very dubious calls in our favour so we can not reallistically complain about that one.

This to me is one mighty wake up call for the team. Maybe it is a good thing we lost today and at least our shortcomings have been highlighted at an early stage of the season.

The defending down Fosters side again was diabolical and he should never have dropped that ball. From the moment that ball hit the ground i felt it was not going to be our day. The interception from Wheeler probably flattered the score for us.

God I am so disappointed. We played so well in the first half too but in the end we got exactly what we deserved !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Totally agree!!!


our defence 'this season' is a disgrace iv seen better defence from local teams in my rugby days,


Royce needs to sort this! if not then he will be out or someone will be end of!


i saw a headline in the paper about Hudds coach Nathan brown apparently maybe on his way to us if royce doesnt earn a new deal and i dont think its a bad idea, people can slate and disagree but if we want to win ANYTHING we need this defence sorting or else we can look forward to looking like an average team defensively


also well done to Catalan though they saw how rubbish our defence was and played on it!!!

Fair result in the end.

Foster needs to get a grip. His attempted catch and fumble gave them the momentum, yet 2 mins later he comes off his wing to aid a tackle which left an unmarked man on the wing, ball goes out he runs the line passes it inside and another try for cats, then he gives a pen away shortly after which again results in a try, hes a good kicker but for me hes a liability. Well played Catalans. How we can take a lead like that then give it away is not St Helens.....

Give Catalans credit - they did a 'Saints' on you. Cracking finish to a game. You've done it often enough!

Give Catalans some credit the "mighty" Saints can get beat now and again ya know

I couldn't go through illness - I feel even sicker now!

It was like watching a car crash in slow motion. We had warning of this letting in 36 points last week by a team like HKR. We were weak around the margins of the ruck area which then spread to the ruck area itself. Foster hasn't a clue how to defend.

Back to the drawing board for defense.

I know, as if we put 36 points on ya! So Catalans are worse than us then? And they beat you haha!

He is paid more so to justify that he has to play, plus he is Australian so that automatically means he is better !

Being honest and I'm pinching another poster on here's words but we looked poorly coached tonight, clueless in defence especially. When things were going belly up what did Royce do? well nothing , he left the Lance substitution till way too late and then he took the wrong person off, it should have been Wello.

We need to pick our best 17 and for me Wello, flanders and at the moment Foster wouldnt be in it.

feck off back to your council estate/fishing boat you boring little troll

The thread title says it all. Catalans did well but some of them attempts at defence were awful.



I have been impressed with Dixon from what I've seen of him this season, not been impressed with Flanders