Is he coming back next year? Haven't seen anything mentioned in the press.

Hopefully not.

Doubt we will see him again. Be nice to see him make a livign from the sport though, and ofcourse if he did make it and become top drawer he woudl hopefully want to come back to the redvee for buttons.

Staying at Celtic

Lets hope he doesn't come back. Worst 'next best thing' we have ever produced

I hope he does really well and proves the knockers wrong.

He hasn't got it in him. He was poor in the Championship.

No he wasent. He was far from poor. made more of an impact than Chris Dean and he is 3 years younger.

Also been one of the best performers in the Celtic backline the last few months, after breaking into the team.

He was garbage at Widnes when I saw them on Sky. I've not seen him at Celtic.

Would you have him back at Saints?

No i wouldent because we have decent youngsters comming thru. However i wouldent call the lad poor. Had some bad games for Saints did Ste. Jonny Lomax is currently having a couple of shockers (at the same age Ste was) Yet Lomax will be a GB international.

Fair enough. That's a big call on Lomax too. Where do you see him succeeding? Fullback or halfback?

i still laugh when he said he wanted "to be the next jamie lyon"

Wish him all the best - would be great to see him kick on and become a top centre.

Think he was put under ridiculous pressure by Saints fans to be the finished article at an early age then ridiculed when he wasn't.

A very respected Widnes supporter friend of mine told us before this season that he had been impressed with Dean but Smith and, especially, Tyrer, had been hugely disappointing.