To be fair Wilkin has been an above average player for the saints in the past, but, past is now the operative word. He has outplayed his usefulness and is now a liability with his lack of concentration, game awareness and with the number of penalties he concedes. Also his timing of passes is strangling the saints attack as most of his passes are directed at players who are motionless. His constant niggling and cheap shots cost his team mates a lot of energy during the course of a game. He is also guilty of stargazing which is unforgivable in the professional game. I am really disappointed he has been awarded a further contract as I cannot foresee him contributing to a future Saints team.

Wilkin hasn't been great for a while now, but offers way more to the team than savelio in terms of game management. He still has a good kicking game, he can still make a reasonable job of playing at #7 when required, which has been an awful lot over the years, and he still gets though a lot of defensive work and long minutes every week. Savelio is in no way a like for like replacement particularly with his attitude. Players like savelio and eastmond think they are too good for the club. Let them go.

In terms of game management Wilkin didn't play in the first 30 mins against Wakey and it showed, the pack was head down barge down the middle one at a time then after the 5th tackle Walsh kicked down field . When Wilkin came on we played with a bit more variation in the forwards so he does bring something the team whether its for better or worse.

With the amount of Ex-Saints players running the show at Langtree park a lot of you seem surprised that Wilkin get a shirt every week and plays in key pivotal positions and keeps players out who specialise in them positions. it's almost... It's almost as if the top brass at Saints are looking after certain players...

Typical Wilkin Bashing, Roby was poor last night and it just gets ignored. Wilkin is a quality, vastly experienced forward, yes he has the odd brain fart but who doesn't.

Roby was poor Thursday, in fact he was pretty awful but his poor games are one or two times a year and I'm sure that counts for something.

Wilkin imo has to play at the moment as he's only guy out here that is captain material (not a good captain tho) and we lack leaders so he has to play.

However, his actual performances are not good enough. He's neither a forward as he's to small and not strong enough running the ball, nor is he a halfback as he's no class, no pace and not enough rugby brain..