They lost 25-16 to Warrington in the final though!

Let's look at it another way.

We've had potter, Royce, rush and Brown all take charge in recent years and all have failed!

I know the squads have changed over them periods but not by much.

Could it be the players just ain't good enough?

Yep!

That's my way of thinking to. Maybe he could get that few extra % out of them but IMO you could put any coach in the world in charge of this team and wouldn't win anything.

I could name players IMHO ain't good enough but I know I'd get shot down.

Of todays team to 2006 there would only be Roby be good enough and he would only get a bench spot.

Yes your probably right. IMO the are players that have been praised so much this year that ain't all that great.