Quote Teessidewire="Teessidewire"Rogues. Did you take into account the fact that the ball was long gone, it was on O'Brien's blindside, and the fact that he hit the base of the skull? Horrible cheap shot and straight red for me.'"
I didn't think it was that late, I'll have another look sometime later (wife has me in decorating mode

) It was a definite shoulder charge and worth a penalty, I'll go with whatever the disciplinary decides, that's their job.
What about the Wilkin incident on Charnley in the first half? Accidental?