Solid. Did his job well.

I like his variety of passing, he looks fully aware of the defence moving up at the play the ball and gives the ball width. Follows up well on the kick and chase, seemed to work some combinations with LMS and Perry today.
Thought he has fitted in well over the weekend games, certainly looks a better option than having Lance at 9.

Noticed in the warm up that he was talking to Cunningham for a good couple of minutes about something, moving his hands like he was passing a ball. He was also talking to LMS and Flanagan a lot after we'd scored a try. Wonder whether he's still asking about plays etc?

I think he did a good job again today. Has a good distribution and gets us moving around the field. He's a 100x better than Hohaia in that position, although that's not hard!

How old is he? 22? If he was in the team coming from the academy I think people would be a lot more positive about him. People seem to have listened to the Salford fans a little too much.

I'm not saying that we should get rid of Roby, but it's clear that we shouldn't be playing him 80mins every week. If Howarth continues to do a job over the next few weeks I think he could be a valuable squad player.

I agree Albion if he didn't have all the stuff said about him and people didn't pre judge him then everyone would be a lot more positive now but it's almost like they are too scared to go against what they first thought so he is just doing "okay" rather than admitting he is doing good.

Seems to be doing better than most people expected! Good on the lad

you can only judge people on what you see and what you read really and I admit I wasnt too pleased when we signed him as from what I'd seen of him personally and read from others he looked like a plodder destined for a championship club career. I have after 2 games revised my opinion though , he looks like he has some potential. Time will tell I guess