I agree that Foster's kicking could potentially make all the difference in a tight playoff game.

However I think you are wrong to say that Foster is a better finisher than Makinson. Look at some of the tries Makinson has scored this season, Leeds away, Catalans away, Huddersfield at home all good examples. He knows how to get his body in the right position to squeeze in, sometimes putting the ball down with one hand when in mid-air. Apart from Leeds away when Foster moved the ball around his back, I don't recall him scoring too many tries that made me think "wow that took some finishing."

So Foster is the better goalkicker, but Makinson is better in every single other area of the game in my opinion.

Ditto here.

Jamie is a top lad! He can be a little vain but he's great with the kids signing autographs and even having a pass about with them down a brook.

Only in terms of the points they accumulated in their Saints careers, not them as players

As a huge JL fan I'd never contemplate such a thing.

He's a lovely lad, tweeted him last year when he said he was bored, he replied, came down and did a kicking session with Brook U16s, gave them his boots and coat, sent his grandad the week after with a training top for the man of the match as he was having a hernia op. Friendly, unassuming, brilliant with the lads.