Been reading on here a while and don't know if this has come up in the past but was wondering who people thought have been Saints biggest flops. I reckon for me it has to be Steve Hall,the worst winger ever, he was terrible at times and remember him bombing a load of chances at Wilderspool which we drew but should have won easily, Tim Jonkers wasn't too far behind him either.......

Tricky Trindall or Stuart Evans.

Lock it.

Evans at least played two or three decent games. Indeed, he had plenty of potential to be a first class prop - but only with his weight under control.

Brimah Kebbie & Mike Carrington, on the other hand ...

Tim Jonkers ? Talking out of your ar%e there. 100% grafter , tackling machine. In a world of reduced interchanges players of his ilk would be worth their weight in gold unlike 10 minute men.

Paul Davidson, waste of kit.

Michael O'Connor overpaid waste of space, fatty vaulting was here to carry his bags, another waster

Gary Grienke

Ricky Cowan

Michael Smith

Michael O' Connor without a doubt.

Brimah Kebbie came with a big reputation and did nothing and Stuart Evans was another huge flop.

Gary Wheeler.

Josh Perry

agree with Div about Jonkers - great player.

All the usual suspect already mentioned so my answer is Jamie Lyon.

Not that he was a flop of course, I just recall the mickey taking we got on here from pie eaters about a "fat pig hunter" we had signed - and how he would be a flop.

Lol.