IMO everybody is jumping on the band wagon and forgetting that we are only a couple of games into he season.

Okay so we aren't playing up to the standard that we all expect however i believe we have a very good squad that will once again compete for honours this year. As the season goes on we will get better and i believe the team and coaching set-up will begin to start working well together.

Its EARLY days

Aside from the halves where we are lacking experience (and possibly commitment) I don't have a problem with the squad. Given the difficulties of pushing the new stadium through (especially the cost) and the unfavourable exchange rate for NRL imports it would be silly to expect great things. Our forward pack - when fit and functioning - is still pretty formidable and we are in a stronger position in the backs with the addition of Shenton's foot speed and the emergence of Lomax, Wheeler, Foster etc.

We have enough talent to cause anyone problems. But talent counts for naught if the team spirit isn't there. Look at Wigan under Millward. Granted, that squad bears no comparison to the current one. Nevertheless, it was still too good to be languishing at the foot of the table.

Without team spirit even then strongest can be weak.

This statement sums it up and we saw it coming last season as Cunningham was winding down the time spent on the pitch, it was like a disaster and sinking ship if Cunningham was not there, no team or its players mind should rely solely on one player, al;l clubs have had stars like Cunningham but they come and go!

Absolutely. Unfortunately, Simmons has been tasked with teaching our team how to play without Cunningham and his leadership. Some fans think this should have happened instantly just because Maguire turned a side which had already been in about three semi finals into a final winning side in one season. He had a totally different job. All he had to do was basically what Anderson did with us: turn an almost there team into a there team, and by the same means: tweeking the defence and instilling a must win attitude.

However, Simmons not only has to enable the players to unlearn the old ways and learn some new ways, he has to do it without two functioning halfbacks as well as an injured loose forward and fullback, both of which are key positions to attack. He wasn't banking on that and our injuries plus other factors in those positions will undoubtedly have undermined his ability to formulate a post-Cunningham style of play.

Bet you still finish top four though.

He ****ing should have been!

It doesn't look like he's teaching anyone anything. I try and take notice of people who know more about the game than I do and not get carried away with the emotional ramblings that emerge from a lack of constant success.

Most of the 'authorities' on the NRL opine that Royce, whilst a top fella, ain't a first class coach. Our performances this year amply demonstrate that we lack a strategy, modus operandi and any appreciation of what leadership entails.

2 captains. No successful team has TWO captains. It dilutes leadership not the opposite. It's like being at work and having 2 bosses.

Call it early. Call it transition. Call it injuries. Call it loss of experience. Good coaches make things happen quickly. Maguire at Wigan. BenneTt at St George. Bellamy at Melbourne.

I could go on.

We have second best. We need the best. We deserve the best.

We haven't got the best.

Ok, let's take those two. As I have just said, Maguire had all the materials to hand. He had a team that was 80 minutes away from a Grand Final (and possibly CC final too, but I can't remember) at least two seasons on the trot. All Maguire has had to do is put the finishing touches to what was already a pretty good set up and those touches were a tough defence and a winning attitude. Anderson did exactly the same to us but he came halfway through a season and we had important injuries at a vital time, although we still managed to get the League Leaders Shield in his first half season with us.

Bennett took TWO SEASONS to get St George to a Grand Final win, I believe.

Royce Simmons may be a crap coach, he may be an average coach or he may be an extremely good coach. However, five weeks into his first season at a new club, especially given his lack of player availability, the lack of consistency within the team, the Kyle Eastmond saga and the unsettlement of Saints in this transitory year, is no time at all in which to be making anything like accurate judgements of his abilities. It's just ridiculous.


What do these 'authorities' in the NRL say about Daniel Anderson? I'm curious because he got sacked, presumably because the Eels thought he wasn't up to the job, and yet look what he did at Saints. The NRL is not heaven. It's pundits are not gods.

And you have been closer, you have been to three GF on the trot. There are quite a few fans who have been waiting for the fall of Saints and a few more that have been predicting it for years, you have coped well with change, the loss of players and the change of coach so far. May bee KC going is just one two many. Andy Farrell carried us for the last two years he was at the club. Once he went there was no one with the same Wigan ethic left, the Wigan way! We went through coaches like they where ten a penny, looking for some one to take us back to where we where. The main problem we had, we thought it was all the coaches fault, it wasn't. MM has done a fantastic job at Wigan but don't be fooled its all down to him. SW and Rads are as vital. If you have not read Radlinskis book, do so, it explains allot. You may start to understand why a few are comparing the Ashton situation to Eastmond, its not the signing but more to do with attitude.

I agree to the above, another thing is that we are not communicating either particular in defence. Not sure if this 2 captain role is working either, I would give the proper role to Graham with Wellens as vice captain.

Don't think we can make a judgement on Royce Simmons yet, he has had no stability in the side and no organisers at his disposal in the games so far.

If I was doing the coaching role, for the next 2 months (Pyrce) I would take Eastmond out of the organising role and put him at Full Back. Wellens to try and organise from Loose Forward position. We would have to perservere with Gaskell at Scrum Half he is at putting in an effort (with errors) Lomax would go to Stand Off . Don't know why we keep Meli on the Wing when we have Foster who is more reliable at Wing, Meli is more of a danger to the opposition at Left Centre.
In theory the pack looks OK, but is not operating as a go forward unit, for me this is a priority and needs sorting quickly by Simmons as this is where we have lost games so far, we are not comeback kings anymore, giving teams 20+ start (Wire + Harlequins) just means making the score line more respectable in the second half.

Lastly the biggest concern is relying on one player (Pyrce) to make our season, I think fans should accept we have lost the prime component of Stability and get ready for a Jekyll and Hyde Season.