Look at most of his try walkins ?? anyone could score them. Think how many tries he give away he is terrible can hardley catch a ball under kicks !

P.s He lost us a grand final to.

I'm not meli's biggest fan and also not his biggest critic but last seasons scoring record with no out and out centre, no halfbacks for most of the year and swapped between centre and wing is outstanding!

No way was his tries walk-ins, his finishing close to the line is as good as anyones in rugby league!

However, his mistakes out weight his positives and makes far to many mistakes.

I would agree with that.

For all that he might have been the player to score the most tries, I bet he was also one of the players if not the player that let in the most, too. To get a good idea of Meli's value as a winger, the attacking capability that he is has to be balanced against the defensive liability that he is.

It's a shame really as he'd make a good centre if he didn't make wrong defensive calls.

Hes so frustrating to watch!

Yup! He drives me nuts, in all the unenjoyable ways.

Did you expect anything else???? Scott Moore will be next!