I'd have Penny at Saints! I know he makes cock ups but decent coaching would help that and playing him alongside Gidley he'll get space to move! I know it was a different era but Meninga created so many tries for Sean Day... and Penny is definately better than Day. Mind you, Meninga was better than Gidley is. I still believe we could make him a better player at Saints. Eastmond would have to improve his kicking game or we could use Moore at 7? I think Price needs to stop sulking, shed afew pounds and in doing so get his pace back, then I'd have him in left centre with Meli or Gardner on left wing.

All based on the 1 cup you've won in living memory lol

This is the year of the wolf, don't you know.

Penny has scored 26 tries in 39 first team appearances. When you consider the last 5 or 6 games were when he was being used as a scapegoat for our abysmal coaching staff and his confidence was shot to bits i'd call those stats pretty impressive. The fact that saints fans are even discussing signing him shows the talent the lad has. I've nothing against our other wingers, but if we offered you penny or riley who would you take?

If it was either/or, I'd take Riley as he's better defensively [iand[/i has pace. Remember, you're on the Saints board. Our wingers' specialities are having no pace and giving away grand finals through worse defence than I have witnessed at under 10s level.

penny certainly has the raw speed that wingers need given time and good coaching he can become a success in the game i.m.o i dont see why saints or any other club for that matter dont give him a chance long term? christ how long has gardner been at saints????