Quote: St. Etrigan "I can see your point but you would imagine that the same reference point would be used for both rulings - one against the line markings - the other against a fixed point on the runner.
I dont know the answer but I would love somebody to explain it - there must be refs out there who can guide me in this.'"
There is no specific reference in the rules in relation to kicks in general play and how you mark a player as being on-side or off-side in relation to this kick. However, if Mr Cummins does reply I think he will point you to Section 13, Rule 3 as being the general interpretation of off-side and on-side at a kick and that the rules remaining consistent on this rules for kicks. That of course states that players have to be behind the ball not the player to be on-side!
This has always being my understanding of what is considered on-side/off-side for any kick and is the key point.
I do think the rules could be a little clearer on this but I am sure, disappointing some Saints fans, it would talk about being behind the ball, not the being level or behind the player with the ball!
The 40/20 is a Red Herring, because as stated the rule is about the position of a player on the field and not about another players position in relation to the ball.
They are being consistent with the rules... but agree it could be clearer!