I don't think so no, he is to unreliable. His passing is woeful and his kicking game has gone downhill over the last 12 months. Personally I think this is more down to age and the fact he has had a lot of injuries rather than being down to the skills of SL (although in all fairness his passing has never been a strong point).

He has been a great player for Saints but I think the board where right not to offer him another 2 years.

For what its worth, I was never a fan of JC but he became ever more unreliable.
I can't see any inconsistencies in this.
You obviously have the right to disagreee my judgement but it then just becomes a stale arguement.
.

Then you watched his first couple of seasons with your eyes closed or you're just a bit daft.

You just can't resist descending into insults can you?

Are you a member of UKIP or the BNP or something? This would explain your intolerance of any other opinion than your own.

Yep, I think your opinion of Cayless is daft so I'm a racist.

The is a lot like that on here pal.

I'm pretty fooking sick of it to be honest!

Well, if you says "Good bye; good ridance (sic)" about a player who helped Saints to major trophies and whose career is in tatters through injury, expect people to pull you up on it.

I've not said anything about it!

I'm a JC fan

JC was potentially a Saints legend. Unfortunately due to some bad luck, he goes home in the same category as Dave Fairleigh........Not a bad un then

Turn of phrase pal, was speaking in general terms.