Thought it was a harsh red. Expected a yellow.

I know a lot has been said about the passive approach, I don’t think we’ve been overly passive tonight. We have been utterly stupid and riddled with errors. I’m unsure how much of that can be laid at the feet of Smith.

A shocking display and Wigan are not great .

That's Tet and Bentley both missing next week

It was a Red all day , oh and by the way Smith is coach

Ain't over yet. Though Wigan must be scratching heads over how they're only ahead by 8

I also thought yellow, he couldn’t exactly pull out of the tackle but he didn’t need to commit, just dumb.

I agree about the defence, we were containing them well until that shocking attempt on French.

So many errors from dumb passes and bad disapline

its smiths philosophy, as he said last week 'to go looking for opportunities rather than waiting for them'. its kamikaze as we're seeing every week and the pressure on our own line is just ridiculous. The stupid thing is we'd have enough in the pack and outside backs if we played a more composed style. Smith is pushing this style every week without a doubt.

only positive, Giants are sht too.

We don't know how to apply pressure to the opposition. For an experienced half Austin does some dumb stuff, apart from his customary penalties.

Every cloud...

Even I am not impressed tonight.

We have no spine. O’Connor is undercooked at starting 9 but we have very little through the halves and Handley is a winger.

Errors and discipline again and most of it is in the backs, which is tiring out the pack making them less effective.

Not completely out of it yet but with Zane gone so early this will be tough.

The pressure on our own line is from errors and penalties rather than our defence this week

I wouldn't mind the approach, but it doesn't look like they practice their catching and passing, or anything else for that matter. The basic fundamentals of this side are horrendous.

Lisone is a joke ,

Could not get back onside at any play the balls and Sangare is just not trusted to play many minutes

The stats show we score our points in the second half, looks like the aim is to stay in the game in the first half and finish stronger. Rope a dope if you will, but two of our forwards took themselves out of the game, other players have switched off in defence and possession.

The squad is bobbins, uncle Gary is doing it on the cheap, I wish the coach all the best as I am excited by this different way of playing the game, but based on the anger here, he might be another coach who takes the blame on his way out.