I think Keinhorst should be in. But the comment about about our most consistent performer only highlights how fickle and to be fair stupid Leeds fans are. He has had about four good games this year, yet still there is quite a few fans that dine out on it months later. He has been no more consistent than other single player this year. However, to highlight just how poor we are, he should still be in ahead of others.

Keinhorst should be in with a good chance of our player of the season.

Maybe that does show how poor and inconsistent others have been, but so be it.

Even if you think keinhorst's attack at second row isn't as affective as when he's playing centre, and even if you think we need impact around 30-40 mins and keinhorst isn't that sort of player, that's fair enough. But to think achurch WILL bring you an attacking threat and impact off the bench- I cannot agree with that at all. I would say we don't have that player available you are after, rather than look to achurch. He bottles every opportunity he gets, which keinhorst certainly does not. It can't be great for keinhorst being one of the most consistent performers this season, yet seeing that lump achurch picked over him. I hope he does get POTY, its probably his one chance to ever get an achievement like that, and he's one of only a few that's deserved it.

Keinhorst in.

It's comments like this that gets people's backs up with you Gotcha. You come on and make out you're more rugby educated and savy than others. People give their opinions and thoughts but you call them stupid! Whilst Jimmy hasn't been a game changer, he's been the one to put his body week after week when others went missing. This stands out for people in a struggling team.

Just ask yourself sometimes why people have go's at you so often. You're no better than the rest of us. Even with your 'in the know' information you're still watching from the stands and commenting on here.

People on high horses are more likely to be knocked off

Just to be clear mate, I have no emotion whatsoever to what people think. But what is making out more educated by saying what I said? I am interested to know why you didn't quote the rest of the post but just one line? The point is clear, it was the word consistent, he has been no more consistent than any other player this season. For a start, Garbutt must have had at least double figures more consistently better games than him.

The point about fickle and stupid is that this is what always comes out with Leeds fans. It wasn't personal to the person who posted. But a couple of good games and you are suddenly the bee's knees, but player B puts in a couple of bad ones and he will never be forgiven. Case in point Achurch, fickle is the nearest match to certain posters.

This is a message board, with differing opinions, if you don't like that then just stay off it, then offence isn't taken.

He doesn't offer as many meters as some of the bigger back rowers granted, but I do think he offers as much as any back rower we have with ball in hand, both linking in the line and in beating the man in front of them (this season at least).
We should have 4 props playing and a big back 3 so meters shouldn't be too hard to come by anyway.

What has been impressing me about Keinhorst this season is his ability to read an attack in defence and effort to prevent tries. He is often the first to react to a break and does his fair share of cleaning up loose balls as well.
Hopefully we won't need plays like that against fev but better safe than sorry imo.

I think he probably deserves it at this point in the year, but I doubt he will get it.
Many of the more committed supporters will remember his efforts through the year, but I think the average fan will pick a player who stands out more, possibly Watkins if his recent form continues, despite his below par performances earlier.
On top of that, he certainly isn't one of Mac's 'favourites' and(as some have suggested) may find himself out of the team.

IMO this game is going to be a bit harder than most on here suggest for the simple reason that both teams have not played for 2 weeks. The week off will be a great leveller and where we could have expected Fev to fall off in the last 20 under normal circumstances, the fact that we are in play off rugby and 2 rested teams will make it harder than if this was a normal mid season game.
I still expect Leeds to win but it will not be at a cantor. Leeds best chance is to start quickly and get a score or two ahead early on. Hopefully they will not then relax and try to defend a lead. i don't see this being more than a 12 -18pt margin but with Leeds of 2016 who knows

in red hot weather against part timers fitness will tell. tight for a while but Leeds by plenty.

You condescending so-and-so. The reason I quoted that one line is because that's the one you call people stupid!! Yes it's a message board where people have opinions so why do you feel you can slate other people's (calling them stupid for thinking Jimmy has been consistent) but if anyone says anything about you you get all angry. And don't tell me you aren't and you don't care what people say because the amount of arguments you get into show you do.

The same way you want to be able to say your piece, let people say there's. I'm an educated bloke (who has never met you, wouldn't want to and therefore am not your mate) and I can see all sides of arguments. To come out and say your point about Garbutt us fair enough and warranted. But what isn't is calling people fickle and stupid for theirs. THAT IS MY POINT!! You're an absolute hypocrite!!!!

At no point whatsoever this year has Achurch proved or shown he deserves selection ahead of JK irresepctive of opponent.

Really?? So if fans rate JK this season as one of our best/most consistent (You're well known pet hate btw) they're fickle & stupid?

Didn't say he was our best every week, but I can't think of any games where he has given up or been outright shocking, and there are not many in our squad that you can say that about.

Who would you say has been our most consistent performer in all your wisdom?

I'd say at one point Keinhorst was our best performer of the year, but after Round 16 he was reduced to a limited bench role so obviously hasn't had the minutes to keep that up.

I'd be tempted to say Garbutt, he makes massive metres nearly every week and no other prop in SL made more metres per game than him.

Although he shouldn't at this point (even though he's hitting a bit of good form) I'd bet that either Watkins will be given the club's player of the year, mainly because he's been out there every week or JJB who has been an ever present since Round 5 and does a load of tackling and maybe it could be his final year so sentimental as well.....those aren't my personal choices btw just the ones I think the club will go for for their award. The fans player of the year will be an interesting one. Lilley will be a shoe in to win the YEP Shooting Star award.