What I can't work out is if the video ref can without doubt say that the McGuire no try was a no-try because JJB knocked on, but he's not allowed to judge on a forward pass because its inconclusive.

Of course it did love.

Because things such as momentum (for want of a better word) don't matter for knock ons. Look at where the ball was touched, look at where it ends up - if it is in front, it's a knock on.

Different rules apply for forward passes.

He's handed you your ass.

I'm not going to stoop to the comparing jobs level, but judging by your posts I certainly wouldn't swap.

Isn't it therefore treated as a pass under the laws if its caught by a teammate?

Edited quickly to say I think thats the theory being suggested here as I have no real desire to get dragged into this!

Oh you would!!

Yes by proving conclusively in his own mind that a flicked pass was in fact a knock on despite the fact it went backwards!!

Now run along and polish Emma's new boots. TIA

You are wrong, the rule book says so.

Time for you to F*** off again for a few months. It didnt take long for you to embarrass yoursefl this time.

FearTheVee by plenty.

Nah, I like it round here if only to conclusively prove that using foul and abusive language on a family forum is in fact the trait of a little man who enjoys pulling his pants down in front of the neighbours.

You really are a lemon aren't you?

Where does it say its a family forum?

You got banned for foul language anyway.