This. But if he's going to make an error, I'd rather he did it in a game where it was never going to have a material effect on the outcome.

i dont think it was a hall error, the kick from roby? was excellent as it forced him to back peddle and theres no way anyone going backwards can out jump someone with a run up
the fact that roby was allowed to skip away from tackles is where any mistakes were made

I thought I could smell something.

Bingo - Hall was tracking backwards to position himself under the ball. There's no way on this planet he could have jumped.

Excellent kick and execution by Roby and Gardner and next to nothing legal Hall could do to prevent the outcome. No different to when Hall has done that himself to many a defender.

Precisely tvoc.

Ryan was too busy looking at his grand final winners rings glistening in the sunshine to notice him.

Shouldn't be wearing jewellery on the pitch.



Plus, if he wore all his GF winners rings he'd look like Mr T.

my Hai Karate per chance

Hmmm let me think challenge cup medals or super league rings and wcc medals yep know which I would rather have.

I'd rather this squad of 'Leeds All Time Greats' had at least one Challenge Cup winners medal. Not neccesarily instead of any of the above but rather in addition to. Without it there remains a question mark that shouldn't be there.

I think it was good execution, but in retrospect Hall could have jumped higher, and with his back to Gardner shielding the ball