Could be worse we could have Ian Watson

I'd say individual errors and smiths approach to the game go very much hand in hand. He's tried to copy and paste his set up from the bears and it's just not working.

Yes, errors and discipline has cost us tonight.
But there's no structure, no game plan, no organisation and no leadership.
It's all just desperate, off the cuff plays when we do actually launch a rare attack.
Sadly, I'm losing faith in Smith I'm afraid.
We have to give him the chance to turn it round, but things need to change quickly.
This group of players are massively under-performing.

If we don’t make the playoffs, which is now unlikely then get rid. We cannot have yet another “next year will be better”

Another dire performance. Completion rate can't have been much over 50%. We don't know how to build pressure when we do hold the ball. No fluency with the ball on attack. I thought our defence was pretty good, it had to be because Salford asked a lot more questions than us. They looked well drilled, players running onto the ball at pace. Everything we are not.
Terrible

A controlling 7 is absolute priority for next year

Getting rid of Smith with achieve nothing but another year of building as a new coach won’t have ‘his’ side.

There’s plenty of time left this year to turn it around last thing this club needs is another coaching merry go round, Smith was signed as a long term project let him do what he was brought in to do.

FWIW i think we will make the playoffs and not just scrape in.

Agree. Smith is simply not delivering the goods. If we don’t make the playoffs that’s a huge failure. It’s not good enough simple as.

Ooh looking forward to more non challenging questions by JD too which provide no insight whatsoever. Happy to grumble and moan though his commentary but not ask any important questions. Listening to him and Cummins tops of the sht show each week. Granted I'm not one of you poor buggers paying to watch this crap

I’m fast fast losing interest this season. I’ve had enough of the dross over the last few years.

I'm not seeing any evidence of that to prove your optimism, 11 games in and week to week we just look dreadful on both sides of the ball.

Just an example from tonight, we had them camped on their line Bentley rushed out and clearly shoulder charged one of their players we end up on our own line and bentley drops the ball cold. That’s not coaching that’s dumb play by a player.

Im not saying Smith shouldn’t shoulder some of the blame but it’s not solely down to coaching

We didn’t see any evidence this time last year, SL bar wakefield is very competitive this year and a lot can change in a few weeks never mind 10+ games

Its smiths fault he keeps selecting Bentley who’s f**king c**p week in week out, stop selecting him.