Quote: Gotcha "So after all that bitching, nipping, and slapping, are you agreeing that Duckworth looked better than him on Friday or not?
'"
Not at all. Not even close. Duckworth did just fine but Hall was our biggest (and sometimes only) attacking threat. Halls errors under the high ball were uncharicteristic but he more than made up for them with his all round game.
BTW, when have I bitched, nipped or slapped? I've challenged your opinion without calling you a fooking idiot I believe.
Quote: Gotcha "That was the comment I made, and the one where you came wading in telling me I had an agenda against Hall. '"
Yuo said Hall's position was the most at threat. I disagreed. I thought it pertinent that you held a similar negative view about Hall's performance in a recent game where I thought (and the stats indicated) he once again had a very good game. I did suggest you might have an agenda but that's hardly bitching etc is it? After all, you;'re the poster who didn't like JJB because of his facial hair.
Quote: Gotcha "Yet, despite that and me agreeing with you that he made metres before you got your hands on the stats, that's all you have given us, his metres made. I pointed dout that Hall made two errors that gave Hull KR 8 points, and made another two that bombed two tries for us.'"
Doesn't mean you are right. PS, he did more than make 200+ metres, not that one should under-estimate that. I pointed out his tackle busts and clean breaks etc.
Quote: Gotcha "When you look at the metres made and average gains, the likelyhood is that had Duckworth been afforded another 8 carries to match Hall, had the team passed to the right, then he would have had another 80 metres. He didn't make errors that cost his side. He did drop a ball from a shocking piece of play from Burrow that would have been a try otherwise.
On the balance of that, I stick by what I said, Duckworth was the better player on Friday night. But I conceede, as I did two pages ago that I was harsh to say Hall would be the one to leave out.'"
OK, fair enough.
Quote: Gotcha "You know very well what I meant on the dummy half and metres, you didnt' even pick it up until someone else mentions it for you.'"
I rarely know what you mean. I am not sure you do.
