They sang "do it to Senior", to which he turned around waved and pretended he was in stitches laughing. And yes, I was at the game.

oh and thats better then? well done lads

What? Singing?

There was nothing wrong with the songs whatsoever.

However, I do wish Luke all the best. I hope he makes a quick and full recovery. He's a good kid and he belongs on the paddock.

so you condone what was done?

I am no doctor but that is a broken jaw! Thats how it goes in RL, am sure McGuire & Sinfield can give him some words of encouragement regarding missing out of CC final.

Didn't like the young kid who put shot on jumping about after he dropped him, getting beat by 32, 2 mins left???????? But guess he is young and will learn that the game is hard enough without resorting to WWF showboating....... What goes around comes around.

Unlucky Biffa, lets hope Kobe do protein shakes for next few weeks............

It was banter and jokes. I'm sure even the most ardent fan wouldn't seriously wish any injury on a player. There was some stuff I did disagree with tonight and in the past with Cas fans and although they should have stopped singing when it was clear it was more than serious, the content is not serious enough to warrant a fine. Otherwise it really WOULD open a can of worms.

My question to you, would be, have you heard worse on the terraces? Because, trust me, I have. Like I said in my previous post. There were some embarrassing comments made by the Cas fans and I am fast losing my patience with the minority who WILL cost the club fines if they continue on.

no and from what you write normally I would suggest you are the kind that wouldnt wish that. the point is after he was down for nearly a minute the chant occured. had it been instand or nearly instant no one would bat an eyelid, the fact it took so long is the sticking point. Bad choice and there were a lot of ed of people around us and even people who hate leeds (hull kr fans and saints fans) have raised an issue over what they heard

Get well soon fella, that looks like surgery and a season ender, not good. Hope JP is back though, even for a Wire i wouldn't want him to miss a big day out in Wembley.

Oh, yes, don't get me wrong the timing is the issue and perhaps to an extent the seriousness of the injury has affected your view. However, had it been a normal tackle and the player got up, made a full recovery and it had been sang, would you hold the same point of view? Probably not.

Like I said, I've heard worse and probably will continue to do so. The question is now, are people becoming too petty? You're going to have start penalising every club for every player directed chant they come out with.

ive seen people call lack people w0gs and asian people c00ns. ive seen it and if i saw it tomorrow i'd still be just as shocked and disgusted as i was at that moment in time (im sorry for those vile words, but one instance was my uncle who was targeted so i feel vilified to use the comment). the fact is you dont have to see the worst before, its what happened now. still way of the mark tonight and bang out of order

I concur. However, it does matter. Because if you've heard worse in the past that has gone unpenalised and you will probably hear worse in the future go unpenalised, why should this be made an example of?

no im sorry, i saw the picture posted when i got home, i was as angry about it at the moment in time when we werent sure of the full extent in the ground. the guy was on the floor hardly moving for nearly a minute. me personaly, even if it was lee briers i'd still be worried for the lad if he stays down as we know rugby league lads dont stay down for no reason. please stop making excuses, you may not have been one of them but the fans that did are nothing more than pathetic cretins

I'm not making excuses, just stating how things could have changed your view. I can understand your concern: really I can and I'm certainly not negating the fact that timing and perhaps content was wrong.

I was just as worried to be honest. Everytime I see a player go down my mind goes back to Westerman in the Saints game, last year was it?

Your own players were joining in with it and laughing their s off. We said, (as a joke) "if you hate Keith senior clap your hands" and who joined in? Ryan Hall of all people. What a cretin that guy is! Scum of rugby league!