Calm down, lad. It's disappointing but, there's no need to wish harm on the bloke like that.

Disappointing performance by the on field officials and video ref's tonight, there should be some good learning when they do the review at Red Hall. Very proud of the way Leeds went about the job without complaint, and the measured and dignified way Mac and Rob conducted themselves during interview.
We had the moral high ground, this match will not matter in the end, and all neutrals watching will know who really won, despite the score.
Bring on the play off's !!!

Sums it up very well. I would add that we shouldn't take the ref having a stinker personally. Some times the team or individual players have a howler, tonight Silverwood proved that so do the officials. As you say the Rhinos took in on the chin.

Fully agree AG. If the ref isn't sure and refers to the VR then he should not comment and all issues should be looked from the last PTB in my opinion. There is an argument for both captains to have 2 challenges like tennis and cricket which would avoid this sort of senario where bad refereeing has a major say in a result.

In this case the ref had ruled no try so had there been no VR then the try would have been ruled out anyway.

I can't fault out effort, could fault one or two individuals decisions at some points but other than that, we didn't deserve that loss.

The biggest disappointment is the way we have come to expect and to an extent now accept how poor the refereeing can be, I would never suggest rugby league is corrupt, but if someone new to the game watched that game and saw the 'knock on by leeds' in the first half just before the wigan try for example, I'm pretty sure they'd think there was some bias or something socially wrong with the ref.

Bit of a hasty decision. He has little experience at FB but has the attacking abilities as he showed last week when subbing for the sin binned ZH. Watkins is a bit of an enigma and sometimes seems to not be mentally switched on - tonight was one of those times and he would have been poor at centre too IMO. It is not certain that ZH would have stopped O'Loughlin anyway.

its not like this is an aberration from Silverwood though is it. I think every Leeds fan predicted how he would ref against us. Hes from Mirfield and has made numerous comments in the past to the effect he doesnt like leeds RL and our fans in particular and still has a massive grudge following his 'standing down' by the RFL a couple of years ago. There was nothing accidental about that performance.

I think that there is something wrong when you get the same referee in consecutive weeks.
But it could have been worse it could have been Child or Bentham.
Why do we seem to rarely get reffed by Thaler?

Assuming this is a reference to the McGuire 'no try' it was noticed enough by the on-field officials to send it up as a no try.

That said I agree with Gilder when he says having the on-field officials effectively guessing in these situations adds very little credibility albeit it does generally speed up the review process.

I just can't take people seriously who say refs are bent, or the results of games are pre-determined. If you really believe that, why bother watching? I thought it was a terrific contest tonight, and much more open than I expected. Some great footy from both sides (which was far from guaranteed after our dismal effort against Wire), and as for that penalty; yes, it was a pen, to the letter of the law, but they're often let go, and if I was a Leeds fan I'd probably feel a bit hard done by. Still, I'm very happy with what I feel is a deserved win. They are are all union fans in the pubs down here, and everyone who watched said how much they enjoyed the game, and how exciting it was.

Your coach called a ref bent a few weeks ago.

Just on the forcing the ref to make a decision thing; I've been used to seeing it in the NRL and was in favour of its introduction into SL. But, funnily enough, it seems to have brought up so many incidents this year, both here and in Oz, that I'm actually changing my mind about it now.

Yes, and more fool him for speaking like that, however literally he meant it. I stand by my comment.

Maybe i was a little over emotional.....but i do honestly believe the video ref creates more controversy than it solves. There seems to be no consistency when to call for it and it still more often boils down to subjective opinions. It most definitely detracts from the excitement of the moment and to have such exciting flowing rugby repeatedly scrutinised for technical infringements is not healthy for the spectator sport it is meant to be.

I have stated elsewhere it was a cracking match with some lovely footy from both sides and a draw would have been a fair result. Such is sport. Funny how your lads always seem to be written off on your forum the week before they play Leeds.....? Williams always seems to get stick but whenever i see him (against Leeds ) he looks to be a real star in the making ...your much maligned forwards also stood up.
Cuthbertson is still head and shoulders above any though....and if Garbutt had made it you would def have lost....maybe.