Not starting a argument but do people honestly think the tackle on green was a fair tackle. Because he went to see a specialist and it has just being announced he is out for the season?

and?

Does an injury automatically mean a tackle was illegal?

nothing wrong with it. its a tough game but injuries happen

100% agree - and people need to realise that he toughness is a massive part of the appeal to many involved in the game... Yes stamp out foul play, but don't go too far....

On injuries from big hits... I remember Konrad Hurrell jamming in and absolutely smashing the living daylights out of Cameron Ciraldo in the Tonga/Italy World Cup match at Halifax... Ciraldo suffered a ruptured spleen and retired.... He's now a VERY well thought of coach in the junior ranks at Penrith. By all accounts a couple of NRL clubs have been sniffing around him, but Penrith are adamant he's a fundemental part of the long term coaching set up of the club.