I listed who I thought the 3/4 FB were on the previous thread. So as you say no point going over old ground

Hall doesn't need an op but he's still facing 3 or 4 weeks out... www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-7199479

Hall doesn't need an op but he's still facing 3 or 4 weeks out... www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-7199479

Here's a novel idea. Who's next man up among wingers in the 19s - presumably Tommy Brierley or Ryan Jones?

Why not give them a go before we start shifting players out of their usual position, particularly young players who are going to find the transition to SL difficult enough as it is?

Thanks for replies. Finish work a bit earlier today so going to turn my place upside down looking for it. I used the £10 shop voucher already and found the 2015 handbook thing somewhere completely random by itself, which makes me think the travel voucher is doing its own thing somewhere in the big, wide world. Thanks.

I meant JP where Leuluai is, sorry.

they need to be at the required standard cant just play them regardless just because you have a gap.

You mean using our Academy?

It'll never catch on......

Did Joe Vickery get sent down? we could get him back for a few weeks.

Agreed. But you also need to play the player who is going to be most effective in that position. Is an out of position Golding necessarily a better option than a "lesser" player who understands and is used to playing the position?

If we were short of half-backs, nobody would be suggesting playing Carl Ablett there ahead of Jordan Lilley, despite Ablett clearly being the more talented player of the two.

I agree with this. I would rather have a lesser and younger kid who knows the position playing there than a better and older player who doesn't really have the understanding or attributes to play the role well. You then shoot yourself in the foot twice - losing the player you have moved in the position he is competent in, plus carrying someone in a position they don't really know best what to do.

If the wingers in the U-19s don't understand he requirements of being a winger, then best off putting someone else there who doesn't totally either, but is a better player overall.

If the U19 wingers are really switched on with their role understanding, but are a bit naïve and need more experience - get them in.

It used to totally peck my head in the football when situations like this arose; managers would usually play a midfielder or full back in defence, that was totally clueless rather than playing a young defender who although wet behind the ears, at least had a grasp of the requirements and subtleties of being a defender.

We'll be missing: Chase, Hauraki, J Griffin, Paterson, Lee, Locke, A Walne, J Walne. We have G Griffin out on loan at Wakefield and I don't think he can be recalled yet, so I expect young Matty Gee will make his super league debut.

1. Niall Evalds
2. Greg Johnson
3. Junior Sa'u
4. Mason Caton-Brown
6. Theo Fages
7. Michael Dobson
8. Adrian Morley
9. Liam Hood
10. Scott Taylor
11. Matty Gee
12. Jason Walton
13. Harrison Hansen

14. Lama Tasi
15. Darrell Griffin
16. Carl Forster
17. Maybe Locke?

forgot about Darrell Griffin. easily done i suppose.

Loads of FB's and centres make quite a few of there first senior appearances on the wing. It's not exactly like we'd be putting a prop on the wing by going with Golding there. Watkins, Hardaker, Lee Smith to name but a few who started off there mostly at the start.

1. Hardaker
27. Handley
3. Watkins
20. Keinhorst
28. (Ryan) Jones
18. Sutcliffe
6. McGuire
17. Cuthbertson
9. Aiton
10. Peaocck
12. Ablett
14. Ward
13. Sinfield

7. Burrow
16. Achurch
19. Singleton
22. Yates

Billy McDermott and Ryan Jones are the wingers in the U19s IIRC. From what I've seen both are WAY off SL standard at this time,