That's one critique (from early 2009 was it?), there were others from the same thread you could have used but I'm sure any interested posters will be able to read them all and judge for themselves.

How does the dummy half get past the bloke in front of him, you know, the one who's just played the ball? Does the previously tackled man disappear up his own asshole? If so were you the previously tackled man?

Maybe more Carl Gibson than Jack Gibson, but I have my moments....

Not if the players were coached on how to defend this way. Each player would go to first or second marker depending on if they should be to the left or right of where the ptb is.

Your second comment, as G1 has already said, is spot on, and illustrates nicely the biggest issue I have with our defence so far this year. 1 on 1 we are ok (good even) but the communication between defenders is terrible at times. This is also down to coaching, or should I say lack of it...

It was from last season, yes. The season when Hall earned interantional honours and was probably the best winger in the whole competition.

February 2009. Brrr.

Edinburgh was the turning point in Hall's season for me. When Lauitiiti released him down the wing and he took on and skinned Greenshields, taking many a good judge by surprise. He never looked back after that score. Reminded me of Jim Fallon going the length at Don valley to everyone's surprise, giving him the confidence he'd lacked in his own pace.

Hall has made the best of his abilities to this point although he's suffered this season from a diminished left side threat posed by Leeds generally. Still the first named outside back on the team-sheet.

Yes, no longer a stop gap it would seem.

All players are stop gaps until a better one comes along. Sometimes they don't come along or are overlooked when they do and then you have to endure a stop gap career. I'm sure we can all think of our own appropriate examples to insert here.

Wasn't he behind incumbant international and grand final match winner Lee smith at that time?

Smithy played right centre last year mate.

No. Grand Final match winner Lee Smith played full back in the 2008 season, a season in which he and Hall shared time on the right wing.

In 2009 Smith played most of his rugby in the right centre and Hall on teh left wing.

HTH,

Fancy answering the question or would that be too much to ask, because you can't. I'll repeat it just in case you have forgotten.

How does the dummy half go straight through the middle when the man who has just played the ball is stood there?

btw, if that's your idea of "handing someone their ar5e" it's back to troll school for you sunshine...

I would like to see Smith given a run at left centre which will suit him better that on the right.