Quote: Gotcha "Your not worth it. You dug the hole for yourself with your silly post, backtracking won't get you out of the hole.
HTH.'"
OK, I will try and interpret your gibberish and respond to what I think you were trying to say.
Quote: Gotcha "Only an buffoon would come on a thread and use an argument of non picked for one position in a subjective fantasy team as proof of not good enough.'"
OK, I think you're trying, bless you, as best you can, to say that it's foolish to use a player's omission from the Dream Team as an indication that said player is not "good enough".
If that is what you're trying to say I should point out not only can you not type a sentence that is English (and I am not picking on typos, your post was gibberish) but that is not what I was actually saying.
I'd agree with your attempted proposition that it doesn't mean a player isn't good enough just because they don't make the dream team. However, when certain posters tell us that Buderus is head and shoulders above any other hooker in the league I think his lack of recognition by players and media alike for any individual honours during his time in Super league is good indicative evidence that is clearly not the case. If he were head and shoulders above, say Monaghan and Roby in anyone but Bywater's opinion I am sure he would have been so recognized.
Quote: Gotcha "Whilst at the same time argue another player is the best despite not even been picked in two positions in the same team.
'"
I've put this through the gibberish translator and it says you're claiming I've been inconsistent in claiming Hall is the best winger in the league but I can't claim that because Hall didn't take one of the two available wing spots in the Dream Team.
I can see some logic to that argument. I Gave my opinion that Hall deserves inclusion. I think that was a reasonable opinion. I don't think it's comparable with the Buderus situation because.
1. Hall has, unlike Buderus, gained selection over the last three seasons.
2. I've never claimed Hall was "head and shoulders above" any other winger in the league. I can see why Briscoe and Monaghan are there, I just think Hall should be ahead of at least one of them. You appear to agree, BTW.
Quote: Gotcha "Hall's done is job and been very good at it. But it just so happens that other wingers in the comp have also stepped up to the plate this year and put in some terrific performances. There is only two spots available, and IMO rather than Briscoe the debatable spot is Monaghan, but only because of the level of competition.'"