Quote: El Diablo "There's a lot more to being a champion than just playing ability.'"
Schofield was IMO a champion player whose services to the sport were recognised via the honour system with an OBE, he earned 46 full International caps and skippered his country - including to a series win - and eventually was recognised as the World's Best Player when awarded the Golden Boot for 1990 off the back of a series win in New Zealand (arguably would have been a 3-0 but for Offiah's mega gaff in the Test that doubled as a World Cup qualifier) and Schofield would also that year play a key part in the 12 man win V the Australians at Wembley after Edwards had got himself sent off for a quite disgraceful challenge on Brad Clyde.
Offiah and Edwards were still champion players also IMO despite those instances. It would take more than the occasional brain-fart moments to over-write a career of enduring excellence on the field but perhaps thats just my warped view.
Domestically Schofield was awarded the Man Of Steel (only the second time a player had won the award while at Leeds - he remains only one of three in its thirty five year history to do so) he topped the try scoring charts in both hemispheres becoming the first Brit to do so in the ARL.
Quote: El Diablo "On the flip side of your argument, you could wonder, legitimately in my opinion, what Leeds' '95 side would have been like if Schofield was swapped for the vastly less gifted Edwards. The fact that it's a team sport rather than an individual discipline also means that 'champion' players have to give things to the team beyond just their natural ability. The old "side before self" bit. I couldn't tell you whether Schoey did that or not, but it is that aspect of being a great player in a team sport that I think some are questioning.'"
Wonder is right. Wigan finished top of the League seven points clear of the field, they also won the Regal Trophy beating Warrington in the Final 40-10, (Leeds had exited at Headingley to Castleford at the QF stage (14-34) while Wigan accounted for Castleford in the SF (34-6)) before also winning the Challenge Cup defeating Leeds at Wembley 30-10. They also competed well with the touring Australians before going down 20-30 while Leeds had been demolished 6-48 in the tourists previous hit-out.
Quote: El Diablo "From my point of view, I remember him as the best player I saw at Leeds in my youth, and I idolised him.
All I would say is that my recollection will always be that he was a great player but won't inhabit the same level of the podium as players like Sinfield, JJB, McGuire and Burrow (I could go on and on but you get the idea) who were not just part players in our recent golden era but were right at the beating heart of that success, because they belonged to, and created, the team spirit that has made this side so special. That need not be a criticism of Schoey, but in my mind it has made some of his previous niggling about them in the press disappointing, but also a bit on the petty, jealous and bitter side. '"
I couldn't care less what Schofield has said privately or via the media since he retired, that won't ever alter in any way my opinion of him as a Leeds (and GB) player.
I wonder just how effective those fine club players would have fared if having to face the Wigan sides Schofield's Leeds were frequently up against. I doubt the overall record would have been greatly improved ...... if improved at all. The players you mention have only ever been exposed domestically to a salary capped opponent and lest we forget the cap has removed the ability of the top club/s to build squads likes those seen prior to the formation of SL and Wigan set the bar incredibly high as can be seen by their unprecedented trophy haul.
Quote: El Diablo "If he hadn't been such a boyhood hero then I wouldn't care that he was a rent-a-gob, but it still disappoints me that he insists on making a living (and I know he has to somehow) by making unnecessary controversial comments to the press. With his standing as a player, he could, I firmly believe, have made a career for himself as the sort of pundit and commentator that people could actually respect. There is the crux of my disappointment. Not what he may, or may not, have done in the early 90s.'"
Schofield was a regular pundit on Boots 'N All and by regular I mean a fixture at one point as Hemmings once announced his capture for the season. I'm not sure why he wasn't retained but I don't recall him being particularly outspoken or controversial (perhaps that was the problem) in his regular appearances although he held pretty strict views on the use of drugs in sport. Any transgressor should acquire a lifetime ban and Schofield himself claimed he would never even use parecetemol.